Social status

Raising one’s status by doing something good is relatively hard compared to pointing out bad behavior and canceling others. Calling for cancellations/boycotts is an easy way to raise one’s status, and bond as a group.
Aparna Rao

Social status is something that is being fought over constantly and it is beneficial to be prepared for such fights. The entire thread by Rob Henderson on cancel culture and social status is worth a read:

Cancel culture and social status

If there is an activity that reliably results in people gaining status for themselves or their group, then people will do it. If it helps strengthen social bonds between the group, even better

One way to raise the status of yourself and your group is to do something good

But that involves hard work. And it’s hard to unite your group around something that requires effort and potential failure

There is an easier way to gain status and strengthen social bonds within a group.

Broadcast the bad behavior of others. People are more likely to join in this activity

It is more fun for group members.

Canceling people offers status, social solidarity, and fun distraction at little cost

Attempting to move up and failing can be hard to accept. But trying to bring others down and failing is not as unpleasant.

It provides opportunities to identify other adversaries. What or who is preventing you from bringing your target down? People can unite around that question

If you’re a 6 on the social ladder, working up to a 7 is hard.

But scheming to bring a 7 down to a 5 is easier. And more thrilling.

It is much easier to unite people to bring a 7 down to a 5 than to lift themselves up from a 6 to a 7

Uniting to bring someone down has another benefit: a filter mechanism to identify committed group members

Broadcasting bad behavior of others forces people to respond.

Those who agree the person should be canceled can be counted on. They’re loyal

But those who ask for evidence, or debate the behavior, or question the propriety of cancel culture

They have revealed themselves to be uncommitted

Cancel culture is not going away

The social rewards for taking someone down are too immediate and gratifying

The potential dangers too distant and abstract.

“You’ll be next” doesn’t really register for most people. It’s just a set of words.

The immediate benefit of social status and in-group camaraderie registers loudly and clearly

It is likely those involved in cancel culture overlap with those who observe this supposed nearsightedness about climate change (immediate reward/distant penalty)

But everyone favors immediate social rewards over avoiding the remote possibility of future suffering












This entry was posted in Other and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.